Cuneiform Digital Library Notes
2014:14        «              »
On the reading of a-dam-DUNki

Ingo Schrakamp
Freie Universität Berlin

The toponym a-dam-DUNki, frequently attested in Lagash II/Ur III sources and in Šimaški/Sukkalmaḫ period texts from Susa, was identified with Tepe Surkhegan in 1993 by Vallat (1993: 4; cf. Vallat 1997; for previous research, see the references cited in Edzard & Farber 1974: 3-5; Edzard & Farber & Sollberger 1977: 4-5; Vallat 1993: 4; De Graef 2006: 31-32; Michalowski 2008: 114-121). Vallat based this proposal on a Gudea inscription which commemorates the construction of a sanctuary of the “mistress of a-dam-DUNki” and was said to have been found in 1972 by the local population at Tepe Surkhegan. Steve (2001: 13-14) and Potts (2010: 246) published a copy, transliteration, and translation; Steinkeller (2013: 299 n. 44) provided an improved reading.

This identification suits the fact that a-dam-DUNki was incorporated in the Ur III gun2 ma-da belt and was reached from Sumer by boat (Steinkeller 2013: 297). It also matches Michalowski’s proposal to identify a-dam-DUNki as the central city of the land of Awan (Michalowski 2008: 115). It was thus accepted by Lafont (1996: 91), Steve (2001: 12), De Graef (2006: 32), Krebernik (2006: 74), and Steinkeller (2013: 299). Potts (2010: 246-247) and Michalowski (2008: 115 n. 20) questioned whether the inscription came from Tepe Surkhegan and rejected this identification, but Gasche (apud Steinkeller 2013: 299 n. 43) confirmed its provenience, so that the equation Tepe Surkhegan = a-dam-DUNki seems established.

The identification also has consequences for the reading of a-dam-DUNki. The conventional reading, a-dam-dunki, was proposed by Scheil and Poebel on the basis of an alleged etymology with Elamite Haltamti, but most scholars nowadays reject this (Vallat 1993: 4; Vallat 1996; De Graef 2006: 31-32; Krebernik 2006: 64-67, 74; Michalowski 2008: 115 with n. 19). Civil (1998) suggested the reading a-dam-šaḫ2ki, assuming that the Sumerian term for a container, duga-dam-šaḫ/šaḫ3 = adamšaḫû, was derived from the toponym and related to the animal name dam/dim3-šaḫ/šaḫ2/šaḫ3. This was considered hypothetical by Michalowski (2008: 115 n. 19), and rejected by Krebernik (2006: 74), who instead entertained the reading a-dam-sulki, since the ED IIIb Girsu text Nik. 1, 310 = Selz 1989: no. 310 mentions a place-name e2-dam-[s]ul-la (locative) in a context together with Elamite toponyms.

Orthographic variants and writings with phonetic indicators are otherwise unattested, with the exception of e-dam-DUNki which appears twice in Ur III Girsu (TCTI 1, 668: 29 and TCTI 2, 3795: 17; see Bauer 2009: 256), and a few references without the determinative ki. e2-dam-sul-la also lacks the determinative and recalls localities in the region of Lagash, such as e2-dam-si and e2-dam-sur3/utul2-gal (Selz 1995: 116-117), or the Ur III personal name e2-da-sul-la (MVN 15, 325 obv. 7). But as the name occurs together with Elam and Urua, tentatively identified with Musiyān in Deh Lurān (Steinkeller 1982: 244-246; Frayne 1992: 71; Michalowski and Wright 2010: 107), and appears as a locative in a syntagma parallel to elam-ma “in Elam” (Selz 1989: 540; 1991: 38-39; cf. Krebernik 2006: 74), it certainly refers to a place in the east. a-dam-DUNki also occurs in Ur III sources together with Duduli, Sabum, Susa, and Urua, i. e. places to be located in Khuzestan (see, e. g., Berens 77: a-dam-DUNki, Sabum; Berens 84: a-dam-DUNki, Duduli, Susa; Berens 91: a-dam-DUNki, Susa; Berens 92: a-dam-DUNki, Sabum, Susa, Urua; CUSAS 16, 233: a-dam-DUNki, Sabum, Susa, Urua; TCTI 1, 668: e-dam-DUNki, Duduli, Sabum, Susa, Urua; TCTI 2, 3795: e-dam-DUNki, Sabum, Susa, etc. On the localizations of Duduli and Sabum, see most recently De Graef 2007: 90-91; Owen 2006-2008; Notizia 2010: 273-277). Comparable toponyms are otherwise unknown, and an interchange of initial e2- and a- is also attested for the Lagashite toponym a-ḫuš, e2-ḫuš(ki) (Falkenstein 1966: 27 with n. 13. Note that a-ḫuš is the ED IIIb writing, while e2-ḫuš(ki) is attested from the Sargonic period onwards). Thus, an identification of e2-dam-sul with a-dam-DUNki is likely. This then supports a reading a-dam-sulki. The ED IIIb orthography e2-dam-sul probably either indicates a place name with initial /ha/, which was lost in the Ur III period, as demonstrated by the Ur III spelling e-dam-DUNki, or a folk-etymological orthography modelled on toponyms beginning with e2-dam-.



BIBLIOGRAPHY

Bauer, J.
2009 “Review of C. Mittermayer unter Mitarbeit von P. Attinger, Altbabylonische Zeichenliste der sumerisch-literarischen Texte, OBO Sonderband, Fribourg/Göttingen: Academic Press/Vandenhoek & Ruprecht 2006”, WO 39: 247-256.
Civil, M.
1998 “‘Adamdun’, the Hippopotamus, and the Crocodile”, JCS 50: 11-14.
De Graef, K.
2006 De la dynastie Simaški au Sukkalmahat. Les documents fin PE IIB–début PE III du chantier B à Suse, MDP 55. Ghent: University of Ghent.
2007 “Another Brick in the Wall. Dūrum in the Old-Elamite Susa Texts”, Akkadica 128: 85-98.
Edzard, D. O. & G. Farber
1974 Die Orts- und Gewässernamen der Zeit der 3. Dynastie von Ur, RGTC 2. Wiesbaden: Ludwig Reichert.
Edzard, D. O., G. Farber & E. Sollberger
1977 Die Orts- und Gewässernamen der präsargonischen und sargonischen Zeit, RGTC 1. Wiesbaden: Ludwig Reichert.
Falkenstein, A.
1966 Die Inschriften Gudeas von Lagaš. I. Einleitung, AnOr. 30. Rome: Pontificium Institutum Biblicum.
Frayne, D. R.
1992 The Early Dynastic List of Geographical Names, AOS 74. New Haven: American Oriental Society.
Krebernik, M.
2006 “Philologische Aspekte elamisch-mesopotamischer Beziehungen im Überblick”, in: L. Kogan, N. Koslova, S. Loesov & S. Tishchenko (eds) Babel und Bibel 3, Annual of Ancient Near Eastern, Old Testament, and Semitic Studies (Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns): 59-99.
Lafont, B.
1996 “L’extraction du minerai du cuivre en Iran à la fin du IIIe millénaire”, in: D. Deheselle & Ö. Tunca (eds) Tablettes et images aux pays de Sumer et d’Akkad: Mélanges offerts à Monsieur (Liège: Université de Liège): 87-93.
Michalowski, P.
2008 “Observations on ‘Elamites’ and ‘Elam’ in Ur III Times”, in: P. Michalowski (ed.) On the Third Dynasty of Ur. Studies in Honor of Marcel Sigrist, JCS Supplemental Series 1 (Boston: American Schools of Oriental Research): 109-123.
Michalowski, P. & H. T. Wright
2010 “The Mid-Late Third Millennium on the Deh Lurān Plain”, in: H. T. Wright & J. A. Neely (eds) Elamite and Achaemenid Settlement on the Deh Lurān Plain: Towns and Villages of the Early Empires in Southwestern Iran, Memoirs of the Museum of Anthropology, University of Michigan 47 (Ann Arbor: Museum of Anthropology, University of Michigan): 106-109.
Notizia, P.
2010 “Ḫulibar, Duḫduḫ(u)ni e la frontiera orientale”, in: M. G. Biga & M. Liverani (eds) ana turri gimilli. Studi dedicati al Padre Werner R. Mayer, S. J. da amici e allievi, Vicino Oriente Quaderno 5 (Rome: Università degli studi di Roma “La Sapienzia”): 269-291.
Owen, D. I.
2006-2008 “Sabum. A. Early Dynastic–Ur III”, RlA 11: 478-479.
Potts, D. T.
2010 “Adamšaḫ, Kimaš and the Miners of Lagaš”, in: H. D. Baker, E. Robson & G. Zólyomi (eds) Your Praise is Sweet. A Memorial Volume for Jeremy Black from Students, Colleagues and Friends (Oxford: British Institute for the Study of Iraq): 245-254.
Selz, G. J.
1989 Altsumerische Verwaltungstexte aus Lagaš Teil 1. Die altsumerischen Wirtschaftsurkunden der Eremitage zu Leningrad, FAOS 15/1. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner.
1991 “‘Elam’ und ‘Sumer’ – Skizze einer Nachbarschaft nach inschriftlichen Quellen der vorsargonischen Zeit”, in: L. De Meyer & H. Gasche (eds) Mésopotamie et Elam. Actes de la XXXVIème RAI, Gand, 10-14 juillet 1989, MHEOP 1 (Ghent: University of Ghent): 27-43.
1994 “Verwaltungsurkunden in der Eremitage in St. Petersburg”, ASJ 16: 207-229.
1995 Untersuchungen zur Götterwelt des altsumerischen Stadtstaates von Lagaš, OccPubl. S. N. Kramer Fund 13. Philadelphia: The University of Pennsylvania Museum.
Steinkeller, P.
1982 “The Question of Marḫaši: A Contribution to the Historical Geography of Iran in the Third Millennium B.C.”, ZA 72: 237-265.
2013 “Puzur-Inšušinak at Susa: A Pivotal Episode of Early Elamite History Reconsidered”, in: K. De Graef & J. Tavernier (eds) Susa and Elam. Archaeological, Philological, Historical and Geographical Perspectives. Proceedings of the International Congress Held at Ghent University, December 14-17, 2009, MDP 58 (Leiden, Boston: Brill): 293-317.
Steve, M.-J.
2001 “La tablette sumérienne de Šūštar (T. MK 203)”, Akkadica 121: 5-21.
Vallat, F.
1993 Les noms géographiques des sources suso-élamites, RGTC 11. Wiesbaden: Ludwig Reichert.
1996 “ELAM: haltamti / Elamtu”, NABU 1996: no. 89.
1997 “La date du règne de Gudea”, NABU 1997: no. 37.
ISSN 1546-6566    © Cuneiform Digital Library Initiative | Archival: 2014-07-15